The amount of deferred taxation in company accounts can demonstrate which are over-stating their assets and/or earnings. In the property sector, we have found that those with the highest deferred taxation, normally stemming from asset revaluations, also have the highest adjusted leverage, suggesting an attempt to flatter standard solvency ratios (Shui On Land/Hulic). Outside the property sector, China Everbright International (CEI, 257 HK) and Beijing Enterprises Water (BEW, 371 HK) have a high level of deferred tax which suggests that underlying subsidiaries are far smaller than disclosed to shareholders. This is a consequence of accounting interpretation IFRIC 12 which we…
Read more ›
Research
Insights
HENGAN INTL
SELL: Magic Margins
Nigel Stevenson · 17 December 2018
Short-seller, Bonitas Research has targeted Hengan (1044 HK) as a fraud. Operating margins in its sanitary napkins business of over 50% are far higher than those earned by any other comparable business. We struggle to think of any plausible explanation. Hengan has also accumulated US$3bn of cash, yet continues to raise additional debt. Nonetheless, proving fraud is difficult: any evidence that Hengan has faked its profits is entirely circumstantial. But an air of suspicion is likely to hang over the stock. One easy solution would be for the company to reduce its cash to a reasonable level and repay its…
Read more ›
TONGCHENG-ELONG
SELL: Risky, embellished and overrated
Mark Webb · 13 December 2018
Tongcheng-Elong is yet another hastily constructed company with limited historical financials that has sought a listing in Hong Kong. Taken at face value, China’s third largest online travel agency is more profitable than market leader Ctrip, in what is a highly commoditised business. How can that be? There is huge scope for manipulation given that the group has only existed in its present form since March 2018, meaning that historical financials are not representative. We’ve found evidence of profit inflation, cash flow manipulation and misleading non-GAAP performance measures. Given its business model is inferior to Ctrip’s, we believe Tongcheng-Elong should…
Read more ›
PINDUODUO
Window-dressing rather than fraud
Mark Webb · 23 November 2018
Pinduoduo (PDD) has been accused of inflating GMV, overstating revenues, understating staff costs and, therefore, under-reporting its losses. In our view, the majority of allegations made by short-seller Blue Orca (BOC) are not supported by the evidence. We agree that PDD’s GMV is almost certainly exaggerated, but this is likely well known. BOC’s other arguments are less compelling. Its specific allegations about PDD inflating revenues and understating losses are not adequately established. In addition, while it flags inconsistencies over staff numbers, it is not evident that staff costs are artificially depressed. We argue that PDD is an unattractive investment, but…
Read more ›
Follow Us