Family Games in HK and SG

Gillem Tulloch · 13 May 2016

Given that related party transactions are somewhat of a national sport in Asia and a key component of most accounting frauds, it is somewhat surprising that no-one’s gone through and detailed each company’s involvement in them. Well, that is until now. Yes, we locked two analysts in a room and told them to download the annual reports of every company with a market capitalisation over US$1bn in Hong Kong and Singapore, around 360 of them. They were then instructed to trawl through each annual report and calculate related party transactions as a percentage of sales and expenses. Three weeks later our analysts emerged somewhat paler and thinner. Their results are cause for concern.

It’s a national sport

Over 90% of all companies were engaged in some form of related party transactions in 2014. It makes us wonder if the remaining 7-8% simply forgot to declare them! These transactions averaged 7% of combined sales and expenses which is highly material to profit. A whopping 13% (46 companies) had related party transactions in excess of 20% of combined sales and expenses. However, of these, 31 were state owned enterprises (SOE) which clearly do a lot of business with other SOEs. Who knows whether they conduct business at market prices or in line with government policy? What we’re really interested in are those private companies with a large amount of related party transactions because that’s where minority shareholders are at greatest risk. That leaves us with just 15 companies which we list in alphabetic order below:

RPTNeither Hanergy or Silverlake top the list

It probably comes as no surprise that Silverlake (SILV SP) and Hanergy (566 HK) make our short list given recent news articles; however, they don’t top it. That dubious honour goes to Kuangchi Science (439 HK) although, arguably, it’s because the company was in the process of being taken over. Related party transactions have fallen in 2015 but they are still material.

Who are we to judge?

Let’s be quite clear that we are not passing judgement on these companies and nor are we expressing an investment opinion. Some have a perfectly legitimate reason for high related party transactions. For example, Jardine Cycle & Carriage’s (JCNC SP) car assembly joint ventures sell to its auto dealerships. What all of these companies have in common is that these levels of related party transactions are highly unusual. In order to save on legal fees, we’re not going to talk you though our findings. Instead, we’ll give you a flavour of what some of these companies are up to and you can work out the rest yourselves. That is, unless you want to become a subscriber?

  • Company 1: The largest related party balances of any company GLOBALLY, at US$6.2bn. It is paid interest income on amounts owed to it but doesn’t pay interest on amounts it owes. This boosted 2014 pre-tax profit by 20%.
  • Company 2: Two CEOs have been sent to jail in the last decade.
  • Company 3: Around 45% of expenses routed through two companies owned by the founder. One of these paid the founder an estimated US$22m in dividends over the past two financial years.
  • Company 4: Building the world’s 5th tallest building in China, financed with a US dollar loan from a related party.
  • Company 5: Over 35 pages of connected party transactions.

Now we’re working on the rest of Asia. Time to lock the analysts back in the dungeon again. Speaking of dungeons…

Previous Newsletters:Date
CIMIC Group: Engineering profits30 Apr 2019
CELLTRION: Billion dollar write-down9 May 2018
Asia’s most manipulated market is…8 Feb 2018
SINOPHARM: Not what it seems27 Sep 2017
Hong Kong needs short-sellers14 Aug 2017
CHINA GREENLAND (1253 HK): How Bizarre, how bizarre...24 May 2017
ZTO EXPRESS: Downgrade risks rise29 Mar 2017
CHINA EVERGRANDE: Are its auditors asleep?17 Jan 2017
Aircraft leasing07 Dec 2016
All roads lead to China26 Oct 2016
Related Party Transactions13 May 2016
China: If you think things are bad now...11 Mar 2016
Corporate Leverage10 Sep 2015
Noble Group: What new disclosure?08 May 2015
Noble Group's Financial Alchemy08 Apr 2015
Japan's Reluctant Consumer13 Feb 2015
China's last hurrah08 Jan 2015



Full-year results allay concerns…somewhat

Nigel Stevenson · 16 August 2019

Treasury Wine’s full-year results undoubtedly showed a major improvement in operating cash flow, as receivables declined from elevated levels. While channel-stuffing cannot be ruled out, there is limited evidence of…
Read more ›


Blue Orca attacks Ausnutria

Gillem Tulloch · 15 August 2019

In the 8th short-seller attack on Hong Kong listed companies this year, Blue Orca alleges that Ausnutria has been faking sales and profits. The company’s shares are suspended pending a…
Read more ›


Disappointing vintage

Nigel Stevenson · 7 August 2019

Treasury Wine Estates (TWE) may have inflated profits by up to 50% over the last two years through the use of acquisition accounting to write-down inventories and establish other liabilities….
Read more ›

Free Newsletter


Input your email address below to sign-up to our free newsletter.